Madeleine Schneider

Madeleine Ekeberg Schneider is a graduate student in the Department of Government’s Conflict Resolution program at Georgetown University. Having grown up in Trondheim, Norway and Tempe, Arizona, Madeleine is passionate about climate action and environmental peacebuilding. She previously completed her bachelor’s degree in international studies and comparative literature at the University of Michigan where she focused on environmental management in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. After graduating, she served with the AmeriCorps City Year program in Chicago and Washington, D.C. public schools. Madeleine is excited to combine her academic interests and service experiences to support Burmese youth and environmental advocacy and peacebuilding on the Thai-Burma border this summer.



Film Screening: Lose and Hope

12 Jun

I always forget how different the experience of watching a film with a big group of strangers is from watching something individually or even with a group of people you know. On Sunday, I found this difference to be even clearer when the group of strangers had a completely different collective experience and culture from mine.

On the recommendation of Nan San and Khun Oo, I went to a screening of Lose and Hope, a film about a group of young Karenni resistance fighters from Kayah State, also known as Karenni State in East Myanmar. Having missed the session for foreigners and Thai people earlier in the day, I briefly looked into the topic and watched the trailer, nervous that I wouldn’t understand the context or events of the film. As it turned out, watching the film (with English subtitles, thankfully!) in a room overflowing with members of the Burmese community of Chiang Mai provided an additional layer of understanding I would have missed with a different audience, namely the humor and community resilience.

Film poster for Lose and Hope screening

The film tells the story of a group of young Karenni people turned resistance fighters. It starts with them learning to fight, training to face the military junta who have derailed the country’s hopes of progress toward peace and democracy with the 2021 coup. The film follows the youths’ experiences on and off the battlefield, including love stories, grappling with grief, and the struggle to keep hope for the end of the revolution. In doing so, the film expresses the urgency of supporting the revolution and bringing the war to an end. It highlights that the people fighting this war on the front lines are youth – both in the resistance and the military; they are uncertain of how long they will survive and are unable to live normal lives until the war is over (pointedly expressed in the film’s song).

At the same time, the film still manages to find and create humor, both for the audience and the characters. As Nan San and Khun Oo explained to me on my first day here, humor is how their communities cope – it is a sign of resilience.

I come from cultures where war and pretty much any political topic is meant to be serious. It’s a sign of respect not to laugh or make light of these “serious” issues. And, even though I enjoy political comedy, the aversion to smiling or laughing at such issues is still ingrained in me. So, had I been a part of a different audience, I likely would not have laughed at the scene of a trainee who, mid-shower when a fighter-jet attacks the camp, slips and slides down a muddy hill while trying to put his pants on to join the fight, or when a couple snipers pause to consider whether or not to take their shoes off as they break into an abandoned building to shoot from the roof.

Far from lessening the horror at scenes of combat and death, the contrast between the room full of laughter and collective silence made the grief even more tangible. In fact, this experience made the war real to me in a new and horrifying way. Although I’ve been reading and hearing about it, the numbers and statistics were brought to life by the film’s depiction of the battlefield – messy, indiscriminate, and brutal – and by the audience, including the woman I heard crying in a bathroom stall after the film and the man beside me who looked down during each scene of violence.

And yet, after watching the film, when I was sitting in the courtyard outside the screening room with Nan San, Khun Oo, and their friends eating a Burmese pork dish, the question Nan San asked me with most concern was whether I got the jokes in the film, and she appeared relieved to hear that I had. Watching this film with my hosts and members of the Myanmar community, I found that the community demonstrates its strength and resilience by embracing and sharing both grief and humor.

Posted By Madeleine Schneider

Posted Jun 12th, 2024

6 Comments

  • Intern1

    June 15, 2024

     

    Such a good blog, Maddie! I’m going to make a beeline for this film and watch it with a lot of interest, helped by your insights. Watching it with people who are so intimately involved in the conflict must have left a powerful impression. Love the way you use a simple motif to make some very subtle observations about culture, humour etc.

  • Scott Allen

    June 15, 2024

     

    Very nice! One question: how are the Thai people coping with the
    large number of refugees from Burma?

  • Mary Ellen Cain

    June 17, 2024

     

    Thank you so much, Maddy, for your insightful blog on “Lose and Hope” and of the reactions of those watching it with you. Just the song itself was very moving with the hauntingly beautiful music undergirding the heartl-wrenching scenes. I hope a lot of people see this impactful film and can somehow help alleviate the suffering of the Karenni people. .

  • Madeleine Schneider

    June 17, 2024

     

    Thank you all for your comments – I’m glad to be able to share the messaging of the film and do hope those who wish to see it get the chance. I’d recommend keeping an eye on the facebook page I linked in the blog as the film is screened across the world in the next few months!

  • Madeleine Schneider

    June 17, 2024

     

    Great question, Scott! As far as I’ve gathered, it’s been a mixed reception – both from the general public and Thai government. It is quite difficult to get official asylum or long-term visas, so most people I know here are either on short-term language study visas, lapsed visas, or don’t have papers. The CSOs and some undocumented people rely on corruption to bribe local law enforcement to allow them to stay and operate out of the area. (My first week here quite a few CSO offices were actually raided by police who came from Bangkok, which people suspect had something to do with Thai relations with the junta.) I’ve also been told most jobs in the service industry in Northern Thailand are filled by people from Myanmar and other foreigners.

    There are also ethnic dynamics at play. Since the Shan people share cultural heritage (including close languages and appearance) with the Thai, they tend to try to blend in and are generally welcomed. I’m not sure about the general sentiment regarding others coming from Myanmar, but I recommend checking out these podcast episodes on the issue. I haven’t had a chance to listen to them in full, but I recommend at least checking out the blurbs!
    https://insightmyanmar.org/complete-shows/2024/6/9/episode-243-a-river-runs-through-it
    https://insightmyanmar.org/complete-shows/2024/5/18/episode-239-broken-dreams-in-the-land-of-smiles
    https://insightmyanmar.org/insight-myanmar-blog/2024/3/5/a-karen-refugee-in-thailand

  • Bobbi Fitzsimmons

    June 27, 2024

     

    Your description of this film encourages me to look for and watch it. Sharing a film, or a book, or even a piece of art with those who are intimately involved with it can certainly enhance and enrich your own understanding. I found your description of the battlefield scenes (messy, indiscriminate, and brutal) to be particularly poignant. War is never something to be glorified but should be something we all learn from.

Enter your Comment

Submit

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 

 

Fellows

2024
2023
2022
2021
2020
2019
2018
2017
2016
2015
2014
2013
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
2004
2003