Last week I had the pleasure of attending a ribbon cutting for one of Chintan’s schools. The school is the most recent addition to Chintan’s “No Child in Trash” program, and is made from entirely re-usable materials. The school itself is beautiful and is a beacon of hope for the community, not to mention one of the only buildings with electric fans on the premises.
When I talked to the 3 teachers for some 60 students, some of the challenges that the No Child in Trash (NCIT) initiative confronts daily became evident. For instance, the children are all extremely different - they are different ages, they speak different languages, and they have had different levels of exposure to education - which complicates the single classroom setup. Many of the waste-pickers are immigrants and only speak Bengali or another regional language, so the students find themselves learning Hindi and English at the Chintan schools. Further, while this school itself is wonderful, the facilities are still extremely basic. Specifically, there are no floors. The children and teachers alike sit on thin carpets that barely contain the dirt beneath them. Remember how hard it was to pay attention to the teacher in school? Now try image paying attention with a rock sticking into your behind.
Here is a short video that includes some community reactions to the new school
At the event, I had way too much fun pretending to be a professional photographer; here are some of the most powerful images from the afternoon; to view the abridged set of photos, click through to my Flickr page here!
You would never realize it from the number of photos I ended with, but I was very hesitant to take pictures. It was my first time with the community and I didn’t want to intrude by taking photos of people’s homes and children. I was also extremely uncomfortable about potentially promoting my own version of “slum tourism” after reading an insightful and articulate blog by Kristen Maryn, an AP Fellow in Nairobi, Kenya. However, after a few hours and some rough translation, the camera came out and stayed. Parents actually asked me to take pictures with their children, and the kids were giddy when they saw their picture on the digital screen. Many of the residents actually took out their cell phones and started taking pictures of me! If it goes both ways, it can’t be that bad? Right?
What do you think, would you ever be a “slum tourist” and pay to see poverty? Would it matter if you became a “better” person after the experience? I highly recommend Kristen’s blog, and the articles that she linked, for some interesting perspectives. Here are the links again for your convenience: Kristen’s blog, “Slumdog Tousism” - NYT, “Rich, Famous, and Living in a Slum” -Wall Street Journal, and “Poverty as Entertainment” - Daily Nation.
Tags: #AdvocacyProject, #Chintanenvironmentalresearchandactiongroup, #Clara, #GoGreen, #HumanRights, #Internabroad, #Kollm, #NewDelhi, #Ragpickers, #Recycle, #Sustainable, #Voice, #Waste, #Wastepickers, Advocacy, Chintan, Delhi, Environment, Fellowship, India, Sustainability
[...] status in life. Isn’t this the main compulsion behind the slum tours mentioned before (here and here)? I am not saying that this is bad, necessarily; actually, it is amazing that despite thousands [...]
Clara! I think your character and spirit speak volumes to the people you are there working with and for. And the fact that you are conscious of their perceptions and feelings says just as much. They obviously don’t feel exploited, but excited, and are welcoming you into their lives. And that is amazing.
We are all walking a fine line to some degree, and everyone will have their own opinions on either side of those lines. But I know I truly enjoy reading your blogs and applaud your hard work and dedication!
Cheers, and I look forward to being your classmate at GULC!